The Respiratory System
Critical Thinking Activity
Comments/Discussion
Dictionary definitions of respiration usually list breathing first, correctly defining it as inhaling and exhaling, or, as in fish, the exchange of gases that occurs as water passes over the animal's gills. The second definition generally is that of biological respiration: an oxidation process occurring within the cells of the body, using oxygen, releasing usable energy, and producing carbon dioxide.

We rarely think of the biological process of respiration unceasingly going on within us because it is unseen and not consciously felt. Without it, of course, we are dead. Breathing is another matter. We do not take breathing for granted. All of us at one time or another have had trouble breathing. Perhaps you are subject to asthma attacks, or have experienced heavy smog or dust conditions. Possibly, for reasons beyond your control, you were forced to spend a little too much time underwater. Breathing is something of which we are constantly aware. Without it, the process of respiration rather quickly runs out of the oxygen so necessary to energize our metabolic system.

What happens to us when we go underwater? Click here to find out! What you are about to read is extraordinary! We do take for granted the "breathing" of fish in water, but the fact is that fish have evolved rather different mechanisms and processes for removing oxygen from water. Click here to view some of these.

What has recently been called Carrier's Constraint is an important concept in the evolution of the mammalian respiratory system. Read all about it here .

For Investigation
For each inquiry, write your thoughts in a short paragraph for later comparison.

  1. It seems reasonable that Blood Shift would occur in marine mammals, but why would it appear in humans?

  2. Do you think Blood Shift might happen in all or most mammals? If you think not, please record some of your reasoning, and, if you think yes, please do the same.

  3. What correlation do you think there might be between dying while diving and smoking?

  4. Why are fish so much more efficient at removing oxygen from water than are mammals such as humans?

  5. Why do you suppose that Olympic sprinters and lizards do not breathe when they run?