|
Interactive Graphs
Graphing Exercise: Comparative
Advantage
Why do nations trade? The
principle of comparative advantage can help to explain how countries with different
endowments of resources can, through specialization and exchange, enhance the
economic conditions of their residents. If each country specializes in the production
of the good in which it has a comparative advantage, trade will allow each country
to consume greater amounts of all goods than would be possible without trade.
Exploration:
How can specialization and exchange improve the economic welfare of a country?
The graph shows the production
possibilities for the United States and Brazil for two goods, coffee and wheat.
The straight-line production possibilities curves (red for the U.S., blue for
Brazil) assume that there are constant opportunity costs of production for the
two goods, although these costs differ in the two countries. The different endowments
of the two countries are also reflected in the graph: The U.S. can produce more
total wheat than can Brazil while Brazil can produce more coffee. Prior to any
trade, each country has opted to use half of their resources to produce each
of the goods. Any gains from trade reported in the table are relative to these
initial levels of production and consumption.
To use the graph, click
on any of the bold entries in the table and change their values. Entries
in the first column determine how much specialization a country will undertake
in coffee. Entries in the second column will automatically adjust to determine
the production of wheat possible with that degree of specialization. Click on
the amount of U.S. exports desired, either wheat or coffee. The terms of trade
will determine the amount exchanged with Brazil. The terms of trade, shown by
the green line on each graph, are initially set at 2 units of wheat for 2 units
of coffee. To change the terms of trade, click on either of the boxes at the
bottom of the graph and enter a new value.
Clicking on the Opp.
Costs box will reveal the domestic opportunity costs faced by each country;
Reset will reset all values to their initial levels.
- Which country is the
lower opportunity cost producer of coffee?
answer
- Which country is the
lower opportunity cost producer of wheat?
answer
- Suppose the U.S. wishes
to consume 48 units more coffee than its current consumption of 80 units,
which it could do by devoting 80% of its resources to coffee production. Which
would be better, producing the extra coffee itself, or importing it from Brazil
at the current 2 for 2 terms of trade?
answer
- At the current terms
of trade, how might specialization allow residents in the U.S. to consume
more coffee without giving up any wheat?
answer
- Experiment on your own.
How is it possible for both Brazil and the U.S. to be unambiguously better
off after trade?
answer
- Experiment on your own.
What are the limits on the terms of trade that will allow both countries to
be better off through trade?
answer
|