MOLECULAR STRUCTURE AND STRENGTHS OF ACIDS (15.9)
STUDY OBJECTIVES
- Predict the relative strengths of binary acids.
- Predict the relative strengths of oxyacids.
Binary Acids. The acid
strengths of nonmetal hydrides are related to two features of these molecules.
These are the polarity of the X—H bond (X stands for a nonmetal atom),
and the strength of the H—X bond. The polarity
of a X—H bond increases with the electronegativity
of the nonmetal atom. The greater the electronegativity of the nonmetal atom,
the more it withdraws electrons away from the hydrogen atom. This facilitates
the transfer of H+ as a proton. Thus acid strength
increases as the electronegativity of the nonmetal atom increases.
The strength of the X—H bond decreases as the atomic
radius of X increases. A hydrogen ion is more easily broken away from
a larger atom than a smaller one. This happens because the electron cloud
in a large atom is more diffuse. The smaller the nonmetal atom, the more dense
the electron cloud. This greater electron density results in a greater attraction
for the proton. Therefore, acid strength increases as the atomic radius
of the nonmetal atom increases.
When comparing acid strengths of hydrides in a group of the
periodic table versus those within a period, one must consider both
the electronegativity of the nonmetal atom and the bond energy. Within a series
of hydrides of elements in a group the acid strength increases with
increasing atomic radius of the nonmetal. For example, note the following
hydrides of the Group 6A elements.
H2S < H2Se < H2Te
increasing acid strength 
increasing nonmetal radius 
increasing electronegativity of X
In this series, the electronegativity of X varies only slightly, and so is
outweighed by the more significant increases in atomic radius, as shown below.
|
| |
H2S |
H2Se |
H2Te |
|
| Radius of X (pm) |
104 |
117 |
137 |
| Electronegativity of X |
2.5 |
2.4 |
2.1 |
|
When reading across a row of the periodic table the situation is reversed.
The importance of bond polarity in determining acid strength outweighs that
of atomic radius. For instance, the hydrides of the elements phosphorus, sulfur,
and chlorine show increasing acid strength as shown below. Incxreasing acid
strength parallels the increasing electronegativity on the nonmetal atom.
PH3 < H2S < HCl
increasing acid strength 
increasing electronegativity of X 
increasing nonmetal radius
|
| |
PH3 |
H2S |
HCl |
|
| Radius of X (pm) |
110 |
104 |
99 |
| Electronegativity of X |
2.1 |
2.5 |
3.0 |
|
The smaller decrease in atomic radius is insignificant in comparison to the
larger change in electronegativity. The trend in acid strength results from
significant increases in bond polarity when going across the row.
EXAMPLE Relative Acid Strength
Which member of each of the following pairs is the stronger acid?
-
HCl
HBr
Correct!
Click a Hint button for help.
-
HCl
H2S
Correct!
Click a Hint button for help.
-
These acids are nonmetal hydrides of elements within Group 6A of the
periodic table. Variations in atomic radius are more important within
a group than electronegativity variations. The stronger acid is the one
with the greater radius of its nonmetal atom. HBr is the stronger acid.
-
These acids are nonmetal hydrides of elements within the third row of
the period table. The electronegativity changes more significantly going
across a row than does the atomic radius. HCl with its more polar bond
is the stronger acid.
Oxoacids. For oxoacids with the same structure,
but with different central atoms whose elements are in the same group, acid
strength increases with increasing electronegativity of the central atom.
Thus, acid strength increases in the following series where the central atom
is a halogen element:
In each molecule, the O—H bond strength is approximately the same. In this
series the ability of the halogen atom to withdraw electron density from the
O—H bond increases with increasing electronegativity. As the O—H bond in a
series of acids becomes more polar, the acid strength increases.
For oxoacids that have the same central atom, but differing numbers of attached
oxygen atoms, the acid strength increases with increasing oxidation number
of the central atom. Therefore, HNO3 is stronger than HNO2,
for example.
The oxygen atoms draw electrons away from the nitrogen atom, making it more
positive. The more positive the N atom, the more effective it is in withdrawing
electrons from the O—H bond. This increases the polarity of the O—H bond.
EXAMPLE Relative Acid Strength
Which member of each of the following pairs is the stronger acid?
-
HClO3
HBrO3
Correct!
Click a Hint button for help.
-
H3PO3
H3PO4
Correct!
Click a Hint button for help.
-
These two oxoacids have the same structure:

Within this group the strengths of the acids increase with increasing
electronegativity of the central atom. The electronegativity of Cl is
greater than that of Br. HClO3 is stronger.
-
H3PO3 and H3PO4 are oxoacids
of the same element. The acid strength increases as the number of O atoms
increases. H3PO4 is the stronger acid because of
the greater number of oxygen atoms bonded to the phosphorus atom. In H3PO4,
phosphorus has a higher oxidation number than in H3PO3.
EXERCISE
Which member of each pair is the stronger acid?
HNO2
HNO3
CH4
SiH4
HOBr
HOI
CH4
NH3